Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Will Rhymes 'Fine' After Being Hit By Pitch And Fainting

Jamal Crawford for Caron Butler, Who's with me?


Ok so with 12 games in the books,  there is one thing evident that freakin' irks me.  Jamal Crawford has no reference of DEFENSE in his mind, vocabulary, and especially his game.  We all know that Mike Bibby is horrible at defense, but at least he tries.  Bibby actually gets over screens and manages to pick his man up after help has come to his aid.  Jamal Crawford on the other hand, waves his arm in an attempt to show effort.  I am very grateful for what Jamal has brought to the team and  I have much respect for his offensive ability.  But with the new offensive scheme, his one-on-one skills are less of a need, which in my opinion makes him expendable.

Caron Butler is the guy the Hawks should go after.  In a sense we lose very little offensively.  Caron is a very good one-on-one player himself and can get to the basket.  His 3-point shooting may not be rival Crawford's (when he hot) but he's a scorer and in the new offense he would get his shots.

Caron Butler taking JC1's role as the first guy off the bench would do wonders for this team.  First, Teague will be able to develop more efficiently.  Teague has shown progression through the first 12 games and has shown the ability to be a solid back up and can handle more minutes.  Secondly, it gives greater depth on the wing with two legit SF in  he and Marvin and a capable SF in Mo Evans.  And speaking of Mo, he will be able to play more at the 2 in the backup role to Joe.  Larry Drew will have many more options with Butler in the line up.  (LD could go big with Joe at the point and Caron at the 2 with Marvin, Smoove, and Lion on the frontline)

What does all that lead to?  A completely better defensive team.  The bench would be much better defensively with Caron guarding 3's, Mo guarding 2's, and our "Rondesque" point guard Jeff Teague staying in front of the opposing team's pg.

Why would Dallas go for this trade?  Because they want scoring, Caron hasn't had a good relationship with Coach Carlisle, and Mark Cuban is always looking to make a move that he believes will get his team over the hump.  The numbers work out easily also as both players have similar expiring contracts.

Side note: Tayshaun Prince is a similar player that could help the Hawks and who is available but Caron brings more benefits to have to lose Jamal than does Prince.  Shane Battier's name can also be thrown in the hat.

For the Hawks to really get to the next level, defense is the key.  The offense shows that they can and will score the ball.  Defense is what wins Championships!

Poll
Which wing player is the best fit and the best trade option for the Hawks to get in return for Jamal Crawford?
Caron Butler
29 votes
Tayshaun Prince
14 votes
Shane Battier
13 votes

56 votes | Poll has closed

A FanPost expresses the opinion of the community member who wrote it and not that of the blog management.

Comment 9 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Caron Butler

Plays as much D as Jamal does. So really that trade would just be moving Crawford for a taller, slightly less likely to jack the ball every time he touches it, version.

Prince or Battier, however, would be a significant upgrade defensively.

by danielduello on Nov 19, 2010 6:00 AM EST reply actions  

Why would Dallas go for this? Not happening

Can't eat sushi in Utah, brother.....Landlocked

by dstdeelite on Nov 19, 2010 8:38 AM EST reply actions  

Caron definitely plays

much better defense than does Jamal. He is a solid defender, rebounder, and he has averaged nearly 2 steals per game in his career. But like I said Dallas would be willing to do this trade because JC1 brings scoring and is a perimeter threat. They currently have Deshawn Stevenson starting at SG. JC1 would better fit into the starting role and they still have Shawn Marion for the starting SF postion. Also, Caron Butler and Rick Carlisle have not had a good relationship since Butler arrived. Their player coach relationship is not much better than Prince and Kuester in Detroit.

by jdewayneatl on Nov 19, 2010 3:47 PM EST up reply actions  

T-prince is my choice

T-prince has been a winner, plays fantastic defense, and is just a good all around guy to have on the team. I would trade his defense for Jamal’s offensive firepower. While Jamal can score 20-30 points a game once or twice a month, I am not convinced he is a good fit for Drew’s new offense.

Butler seems to be having a difficult time in Dallas. Now if we can combine Branden Haywood and Butler for Jamal and Zaza, I say hell yes to that trade.

by ATLpaul on Nov 19, 2010 8:39 AM EST reply actions  

I like Prince too.

But I like Caron’s offensive ability a lot more. In a new atmosphere, Caron just may go on a tear and play beastly for a few months which would be great for the Hawks.

Prince would definitely fit well in the Hawks system without a doubt, but I think Caron brings an X-factor. Prince would be a 1b option though.

by jdewayneatl on Nov 19, 2010 3:51 PM EST up reply actions  

Is he available?...

considering the style Moray has built around in Houston, I’d say he’d be pretty locked in there.

http://sportsandgrits.blogspot.com/

by Mr. Sanchez on Nov 19, 2010 9:43 AM EST up reply actions  

Hey guys...

Wiz fan here, I don’t know how much y’all have been following CButler…but we sure wouldn’t mind a division rival taking him on. Caron became a black hole on offense when Gil went down and didn’t want to relinquish the spotlight when he came back…and we’re not sure what happened in between.

LD seems to like heavy iso…which plays to Caron’s strength, which is jab step, pump fake, jab step, pump fake, contested jump shot.do yourselves a favor and look for a better opportunity.

If you still like him, review his performance against SA in last year’s playoffs. He shot Dallas out of every game except Game 3, where his shot fell and he scored 35 points or somesuch.

He was a great guy for us…check this out from our senior editor http://www.bulletsforever.com/2010/4/27/1446162/caron-butler-was-a-big-part-of-the

by Bullet Nation in Exile on Nov 25, 2010 1:52 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Atlanta Hawks.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

4_sports_small
Obligatory offseason rosterbatory thread.
Bhop_small
Ethical concern for playoffs?
Small
The Most Hated Team in the NBA
Small
Josh Smith trade value.
Small
Avery Bradley: 'I'm ready; I'll be ready in Round 2 as well'
Phimualpha_small
So now...TMac's shot is here
Small
Joe Johnson is subpar in the playoffs... Larry Drew is not helping.
Small
Kevin Garnett on Hawks: ‘A better team since we've seen them'
Small
WIN WIN TRADE
Small
You were wrong

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Zaza_pachulia_small hawksdawgs

Walker_hawks_small Jason Walker

339989_2352026010636_1549728496_32463242_1925189807_o_small Kris Willis

Authors

Str8talk_logo_main_200p_small Hawk Str8Talk

317753_2142423076352_1119450085_31772239_660825236_n_small Nate Butler Jr.

Website_logo_small William Sevidal